The "True Alaska of the Philippines": Why Carles, Iloilo Carries the Title
Tracing the origins, the rivalry, and the reality behind Northern Iloilo's most iconic nickname
In the United States, the state of Alaska is synonymous with fishing -- vast, cold waters teeming with salmon, halibut, and crab, sustaining an industry worth billions. Thousands of miles away in the tropical Visayan Sea, a small coastal municipality in Iloilo Province has earned a strikingly similar reputation. Carles, the northernmost town of Iloilo, proudly calls itself the "True Alaska of the Philippines" -- a bold claim rooted in geography, marine science, historical circumstance, and a decades-long friendly rivalry with its neighbor, Estancia.
But what exactly makes this comparison apt? And why the qualifier "True"? The answers lie in the extraordinary marine ecosystem that surrounds Carles, the politics of fish ports versus fishing grounds, and the fierce pride of a community whose identity is inseparable from the sea.
The Visayan Sea Triangle: A Marine Goldmine
Carles sits at the heart of one of the most productive marine zones in the entire Philippine archipelago. Its water territory falls within what is known as the Visayan Sea Triangle -- an imaginary triangle formed by the surrounding provinces of Iloilo, Negros, Cebu, Samar, and Masbate. This triangle, in turn, is part of the much larger Sulu-Sulawesi Triangle, which extends south into Indonesian waters and belongs to the global Coral Triangle, the most biologically diverse marine region on Earth.
This convergence of currents, tropical climate conditions, and a thriving coral and seagrass ecosystem creates one of the densest concentrations of marine life anywhere in the Philippines. Carles' waters yield a staggering variety of species: mackerel, barracuda, sardines, shad, pompano, grouper, squid, cuttlefish, shrimp, prawns, scallops, spiny oysters, various shells, and seaweed. According to a fisheries study published by the Philippine Journal of Natural Sciences, compressor diving for scallops and oysters alone in the Gigantes Islands accounted for an estimated 8,473.5 metric tons of annual catch -- roughly half of the entire anticipated yearly harvest in those waters.
In sheer volume, variety, and economic significance, the waters of Carles are to the Philippines what Alaska's seas are to the United States. The comparison is not merely poetic -- it is grounded in hard ecological and economic reality.
Where the Nickname Began: The Estancia Connection
The story of the "Alaska" nickname, however, does not begin in Carles. It begins in neighboring Estancia.
According to historical accounts, the moniker originated on September 6, 1932, when someone arrived on the shores of Estancia and, struck by the abundance of fish and the bustling fishing environment, dubbed it the "Alaska of the Philippines." The name stuck, and for decades, Estancia was widely recognized across the country by this title. The association was reinforced by the fact that Estancia houses the major fish port in the area -- the central hub where catches from the Visayan Sea are unloaded, auctioned, processed, and distributed to markets across the Visayas and beyond.
But therein lies the critical distinction that Carles has long sought to clarify.
Fish Port vs. Fishing Ground: The Heart of the Debate
Carles' argument is elegantly simple: a fish port is not a fishing ground.
Estancia earned its "Alaska" reputation because that is where the fish were sold. It was the commercial center, the marketplace. But where were those fish actually caught? The answer, overwhelmingly, was in the waters of Carles -- particularly around the 14 islands and minor islets under Carles' jurisdiction, including the famed Islas de Gigantes (Islands of the Giants).
As one local history account puts it with characteristic directness:
"Even though the caught fish came
from the fish port of Estancia, it
does not mean Estancia is the
Alaska of the Philippines, because
a fish port is different from a fishing
ground. Thus Estancia deserves to
be called the Fish Port Capital of
the Philippines and not the Fishing
Ground of the Philippines referred
to as 'Alaska of the Philippines.'"
When traders and buyers from Manila, Cebu, or Negros asked where the fish came from, the answer was always "Estancia" -- because that is where the transaction happened. But the fish themselves were born, raised, and harvested in the rich waters off Carles. The town felt that its identity and contribution were being eclipsed by the commercial branding of its neighbor.
This is why Carles adopted the deliberate qualifier "True" -- asserting itself as the "True Alaska of the Philippines" to distinguish the actual source of marine abundance from the port that merely handled the catch.
More Than Just a Slogan: What Backs Up the Claim
Carles' claim is not just sentiment. Several concrete facts support it:
1. Territorial Waters and Island Coverage
Carles has jurisdiction over 14 islands and minor islets, giving it one of the most expansive municipal water territories in Northern Iloilo. These islands -- Gigantes Norte, Gigantes Sur, Cabugao Gamay, Bantigue, Sicogon, and others -- are surrounded by coral reefs, seagrass beds, and deep channels that serve as breeding and feeding grounds for hundreds of marine species.
2. The Gigantes Scallop Fishery
The Gigantes Islands host one of the most productive scallop fisheries in the Philippines. A study by UP Visayas documented that fishers around Gigantes catch scallops, spiny oysters, and other bivalves in volumes that rival any other municipal fishing ground in the country. The Department of Science and Technology, through UP Visayas' Institute of Fish Processing Technology, has trained local fisherfolk in value-addition for scallops -- producing processed products like scallop balls, nuggets, empanada, and lumpia -- further cementing the islands' reputation as a seafood powerhouse.
3. The Unified Marine Protected Area
The municipality designated 8,646 hectares around the Gigantes Islands as a Unified Marine Protected Area -- a recognition that these waters are ecologically significant enough to warrant formal conservation. The national government also imposes an annual Visayan Sea Closed Season (typically November 15 to February 15), banning the harvest of sardines, mackerels, and herrings in these waters to allow fish stocks to recover.
4. The Bancal Fish Port
While Estancia has the larger, more established port, Carles has been building its own infrastructure. The Bancal Fish Port in Barangay Bancal received PHP 29.4 million in investment from the Department of Agriculture to modernize and expand its fish-landing capacity, establishing Carles as an independent commercial hub rather than merely a supplier to Estancia.
A Rivalry, Not a Feud
It is important to note that the Carles-Estancia "Alaska" debate is more of a proud, neighborly rivalry than a bitter conflict. The two towns are deeply intertwined -- economically, geographically, and culturally. Carles fishermen catch the fish; Estancia's port processes and distributes them. Families intermarry across municipal lines. Both towns celebrate fishing-themed festivals (Carles has its Pangisda Festival; Estancia has its Kasag Festival).
The "True Alaska" distinction matters to Carles not because it wants to diminish Estancia, but because it wants recognition for what it contributes -- the fishing grounds, the islands, the marine ecosystem, and the generations of fishermen who brave the Visayan Sea's unpredictable waters to sustain the region's economy.
The Modern Era: Tourism Amplifies the Brand
In recent years, Carles' "True Alaska" identity has evolved beyond fishing alone. The explosive growth of tourism to the Islas de Gigantes -- with attractions like Cabugao Gamay Island, Tangke Saltwater Lagoon, Bantigue Sandbar, and the ancient caves of Gigantes Sur -- has given the municipality a national profile that transcends its fishing heritage. The comeback story of Sicogon Island, with Ayala Land's resort development and the island's designation as a wildlife sanctuary, adds yet another dimension.
Tourism has brought new economic opportunities: boat operators, tour guides, homestay owners, restaurant operators, and souvenir vendors now supplement what was once a purely fishing-dependent economy. The Iloilo Provincial Government, under its "MoRProGRes ILOILO, More in Carles" action plan, has specifically targeted a 30% increase in tourist arrivals to the islands.
Today, when people hear "True Alaska of the Philippines," the image is no longer just of overflowing fish nets and scallop shells. It is of turquoise lagoons, limestone cliffs, white sandbars, and a community that has built its identity -- and its future -- on the extraordinary gifts of the sea.
Conclusion
The "True Alaska of the Philippines" is more than a catchy slogan on a welcome arch. It is a statement of identity, a claim of origin, and a declaration of pride by a community that has lived on and from the sea for centuries. While Estancia may have been first to carry the "Alaska" name -- and rightfully earned its reputation as a fish port capital -- Carles' claim rests on the fundamental truth that the fish, the scallops, the marine life, and the fishing grounds themselves belong to its waters. In the end, both towns are two halves of the same story: one catches, the other sells, and together they sustain one of the richest fishing traditions in the Philippine archipelago.
Sources and References
1. "Carles, Iloilo." Wikipedia, The Free Encyclopedia. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Carles,_Iloilo
2. "Carles, Iloilo." Alchetron, The Free Social Encyclopedia. https://alchetron.com/Carles,-Iloilo
3. "Carles." PeoPlaid. March 17, 2020. https://peoplaid.com/2020/03/17/carles/
4. "Discover Carles." Discover Carles Official Page. https://discovercarles.page4.me/52.html
5. "All About Carles Iloilo." Blogspot. http://allinthecountryside.blogspot.com/2013/
6. Acabado, C. et al. "The Fisheries Profile of Gigantes Islands, Carles, Philippines." Philippine Journal of Natural Sciences (PJNS). UP Visayas. https://pjns.upv.edu.ph/wp-content/uploads/2022/08/3.-22-19-29-PJNS-The-Fisheries-Profile-of-Gigantes-Islands..-Acabado-C.-et-al..pdf
7. "Island Fishers Learn Value-Addition, Good Manufacturing Practices for Scallops." Daily Guardian. https://dailyguardian.com.ph/island-fishers-learn-value-addition-good-manufacturing-practices-for-scallops/
8. "Tangible Tourism Projects in Carles." Iloilo Provincial Government. https://iloilo.gov.ph/index.php/en/environment-news/tangible-tourism-projects-carles
9. "A Historical Overview of Estancia, Iloilo: From Ranch to Fishing Hub." Studocu / Northern Iloilo State University. https://www.studocu.com/ph/document/northern-iloilo-state-university-main-campus/foundation-for-special-and-inclusive-education/a-historical-overview-of-estancia-iloilo-from-ranch-to-fishing-hub/131146096
10. "Pangisda Festival: Municipality of Carles." She Mae Gomez, Iloilo Blogger. https://shemaegomez.com/pangisda-festival/
11. "Travel Tour Packages to Carles, Gigantes." Island Hopping in the Philippines. https://islandhoppinginthephilippines.com/visayas/panay/carles-gigantes/
12. "Gigantes Islands, Iloilo." Foundation for the Philippine Environment. https://fpe.ph/conservation_site/location_details/gigantes-islands-iloilo
13. "We're at the 'Alaska of the Philippines' -- Carles, Iloilo." Countryside Cruiser, Facebook. https://www.facebook.com/CountrysideCruiser/posts/647000870958293/
Comments